Many rural hospitals still at risk after Oklahoma’s Medicaid expansion

Health Care

Many rural hospitals still at risk after Oklahoma’s Medicaid expansion

Ray Carter  |  November 17, 2026

When State Question 802 went before voters in 2020, backers claimed that adding able-bodied adults to the Medicaid welfare program would put rural hospitals on firm financial footing.

The website for the “Yes on 802” campaign declared that Medicaid expansion would “keep our rural hospitals open.” A campaign ad for “Yes on 802” similarly claimed Medicaid expansion would “keep rural hospitals open.”

In May 2020, the Oklahoma Hospital Association released a study claiming that rural communities would benefit because SB 802’s outcomes included “protecting jobs and healthcare services at vulnerable rural hospitals that have been on the verge of closure for years.”

But a new report from the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform (CHQPR) finds that dozens of Oklahoma hospitals face the threat of closure today.

According to the report, 40 rural Oklahoma hospitals are losing money on services, with 44 hospitals at risk of closing, including 17 at immediate risk of closing.

That was the fourth-highest number of at-risk rural hospitals among the 50 states.

Those hospitals face closure despite taxpayers spending billions of dollars more on Medicaid in Oklahoma since expansion took effect in 2021.

Nationwide, the CHQPR report estimated that nearly 700 rural hospitals—or about one-third of all rural hospitals in the country—are at risk of closing, with 260 rural hospitals at immediate risk of closing.

The report conceded that Medicaid plays a role in the precarious position of many hospitals, stating that “at-risk hospitals are losing money on uninsured patients and Medicaid patients.”

The continuing struggles of rural hospitals, combined with concerns about Medicaid spending and private-insurance costs, warrant a fresh examination of the promises made when voters approved expansion.

Still, many rural hospitals remain financially viable, the CHQPR report says. Stable rural hospitals “receive payments from private health plans that not only cover the costs of delivering services to the patients with private insurance, but those payments also offset the hospitals’ losses on services delivered to uninsured and Medicaid patients.” In effect, patients with private insurance are paying higher rates due to other patients being on Medicaid.

Despite admitting the role that Medicaid plays in undermining rural hospital finances, the CHQPR report claimed the “primary reason” many rural hospitals could close is that private insurance plans “are paying them less than what it costs to deliver services to patients.”

The CHQPR’s proposed solution to rural hospitals’ financial woes is to mandate that private insurance pay rural hospitals nationwide another $4 billion per year, which would further increase the cost of private health insurance for consumers.

The CHQPR noted that there is a “mistaken belief that most rural patients are insured by Medicare and Medicaid or are uninsured.”

“In reality, about half of the services at the average rural hospital are delivered to patients with private insurance (both employer-sponsored insurance and Medicare Advantage plans),” the report stated.

‘Medicaid Expansion Has Failed to Save Rural Hospitals’

During an October legislative study, Niklas Kleinworth, director of the State Health Reform Initiative at the Paragon Health Institute, warned Oklahoma state lawmakers that Medicaid expansion was driving up health-care costs for Oklahomans with private insurance.

Because Medicaid payments to hospitals are tied to commercial rates, he said it creates a perverse incentive that harms privately insured workers.

“The problem with doing that is it naturally encourages the hospitals to increase their commercial rates in order to garner more Medicaid funding,” Kleinworth said.

Some Oklahoma hospital officials have tacitly acknowledged that Medicaid expansion has not lived up to the promises made by backers who claimed it would help rural hospitals.

In a legislative study conducted in 2025, officials with the Oklahoma Hospital Association, which backed Medicaid expansion, said rural hospitals in neighboring Texas are more financially sound than rural hospitals in Oklahoma.

Texas has not expanded Medicaid to include able-bodied adults.

Maggie Martin, chief legal officer for the Oklahoma Hospital Association, told lawmakers that Oklahoma’s rural hospitals “have lower total margins and lower operating margins than the majority of hospitals in the country.”

In contrast, rural hospitals in Texas ranked 11th-best nationally in total margin, and the total margin for urban hospitals in Texas ranked in the top five states. An Oklahoma Hospital Association slide presentation declared that hospitals in Texas demonstrate “the strongest financial positioning among peers.”

During the 2025 meeting, Martin said 53 percent of rural Oklahoma hospitals were at medium-to-high risk of closure.

One national expert said the continuing financial challenges of Oklahoma’s rural hospitals are not surprising if one understands the true impact of Medicaid expansion.

“Once again, the data show that Medicaid expansion has failed to save rural hospitals. As the Foundation for Government Accountability has documented, dozens of hospitals have continued to close in Medicaid expansion states—despite promises of hospital expansions—while hospital shortfalls have actually worsened. Most of the remaining states with the highest percentage of at-risk rural hospitals are expansion states,” said Hayden Dublois, data and analytics director at the Foundation for Government Accountability. “And as the CHQPR report acknowledges, the losses on new Medicaid patients are being covered by higher prices on privately insured patients. That’s not a long-term solution—it’s an unsustainable cost shift akin to putting a band-aid on a bullet wound. Sooner or later, the chickens will come home to roost as the false promises of Medicaid expansion continue to become apparent.”

While the taxpayer cost of Oklahoma’s Medicaid program was stable from 2013 to 2020, it surged dramatically after able-bodied adults were added to the welfare program starting in 2021.

Due in part to expansion, the state faced a shortfall of a half-billion dollars in the Medicaid program this year, requiring lawmakers to raid state savings. Lawmakers also considered placing a ballot measure before voters that would allow the rollback of some portions of Medicaid expansion.

In addition to driving up health-care costs in Oklahoma, Medicaid expansion has also failed to live up to promises regarding health outcomes. The death rate in Oklahoma was higher in 2025, five years after expansion was approved, than it was in 2015, five years prior to the expansion vote. And health outcomes in most states that did not expand Medicaid are better than health outcomes in Oklahoma following Medicaid expansion.

Ray Carter Director, Center for Independent Journalism

Ray Carter

Director, Center for Independent Journalism

Ray Carter is the director of OCPA’s Center for Independent Journalism. He has two decades of experience in journalism and communications. He previously served as senior Capitol reporter for The Journal Record, media director for the Oklahoma House of Representatives, and chief editorial writer at The Oklahoman. As a reporter for The Journal Record, Carter received 12 Carl Rogan Awards in four years—including awards for investigative reporting, general news reporting, feature writing, spot news reporting, business reporting, and sports reporting. While at The Oklahoman, he was the recipient of several awards, including first place in the editorial writing category of the Associated Press/Oklahoma News Executives Carl Rogan Memorial News Excellence Competition for an editorial on the history of racism in the Oklahoma legislature.

Loading Next