Local Government
Portland’s nearly empty commuter train raises questions for OKC
Ray Carter | November 19, 2026
Learn more about the proposed $1.8 billion taxpayer-funded Edmond–OKC–Norman commuter rail: OKCCommuterRail.com.
As officials in the Oklahoma City area are calling for construction of a $1.8 billion commuter rail service, funded in part through a proposed major tax increase, a similar commuter train in the Portland, Oregon, area is drawing so few riders that officials could have instead purchased cars for its passengers at the same cost, a new analysis shows.
The Westside Express Service (WES) is a commuter rail line serving the Portland-area communities of Beaverton, Tigard, Tualatin, and Wilsonville.
Randal O’Toole, an adjunct scholar at the free-market Cascade Policy Institute, recently declared that it is time “to pull the plug” on the Westside Express Service.
“The train is a huge money sink—costing taxpayers almost $95 for every one of the few people who ride it—and hardly anyone uses it,” O’Toole wrote.
When WES was first proposed in 2004, officials predicted it would provide 3,000 trips each weekday.
That never happened.
Instead, the system’s highest trip count was 2,031 in 2014, and by 2019 it had fallen to 1,490 trips per weekday, less than half the ridership initially projected.
Portland’s commuter rail line has struggled to attract riders. Its 2025 weekday ridership was far below both its original projections and its pre-pandemic peak.
Things got even worse when COVID hit, and ridership never recovered because many workers never returned to the office and continue to work from home today, O’Toole noted.
“Ridership crashed during the pandemic, and by 2025 it had recovered to only 488 trips per weekday,” O’Toole wrote. “If each rider travels round trip, that’s roughly 244 people.”
As a result, fare payment covers almost none of the WES system’s operational cost. In every year since 2021, O’Toole said taxpayers have had to cover more than 99 percent of WES’s operating costs.
“Riders in 2025 paid an average of just 62¢ per ride while taxpayers had to cover almost $95 per ride,” O’Toole wrote.
That means the taxpayer subsidy for those few individuals who do routinely use the commuter train is so large that taxpayers could simply purchase cars for those individuals without generating higher costs.
“Someone who makes a round trip on WES every weekday would be getting a subsidy of almost $48,000 a year,” O’Toole wrote, “enough to buy a new Tesla Model 3 or similar electric car.”
Instead of continuing to prop up the train, O’Toole urged Portland officials to shut it down and put money into expanded bus service.
“WES railcars carried an average of just 13 passengers in 2025 (calculated by dividing passenger-miles by vehicle-miles),” O’Toole wrote. “A 40-seat electric bus can easily carry this number, even given fluctuations in ridership over the course of a day.”
Oklahoma City-area officials have discussed creating a $1.8 billion commuter train running from Edmond to downtown Oklahoma City to Norman. The two systems are not identical, and Portland’s experience cannot predict Oklahoma City’s ridership. But WES illustrates the financial consequences when commuter-rail projections fail to materialize and a service attracts too few passengers to support even a modest share of its operating costs.
Analyst Randal O’Toole argues that the public subsidy per rider has become so large that taxpayers could more economically provide those riders with cars or expanded bus service.
One argument for the Oklahoma City proposal is that the train will appeal to some downtown workers who live in surrounding suburbs.
But, as with Portland, downtown Oklahoma City is no longer the hub of office work it once was. Office vacancy rates in Oklahoma City rank among the five highest nationwide out of 92 markets.
A similar commuter rail service connecting Minneapolis, Minnesota, to surrounding communities ceased service this year due to a dramatic decline in ridership that was also tied to increased work-from-home policies.
At the same time, the existing OKC Streetcar rail system, which carries riders along a five-mile loop downtown, stopped collecting even minimal fares of only 50 cents to $3 per person in an effort to attract riders.
In defending the Streetcar's decision to eliminate fares, Oklahoma City Mayor David Holt, who is also a proponent of creating the Edmond-Oklahoma City-Norman passenger rail system, dismissed concerns about financial viability.
“In government, we don’t measure the success of our services by the profit they turn,” Holt wrote, “because they never have and they never will.”
Photo credit: Steve Morgan via Wikimedia
Ray Carter
Director, Center for Independent Journalism
Ray Carter is the director of OCPA’s Center for Independent Journalism. He has two decades of experience in journalism and communications. He previously served as senior Capitol reporter for The Journal Record, media director for the Oklahoma House of Representatives, and chief editorial writer at The Oklahoman. As a reporter for The Journal Record, Carter received 12 Carl Rogan Awards in four years—including awards for investigative reporting, general news reporting, feature writing, spot news reporting, business reporting, and sports reporting. While at The Oklahoman, he was the recipient of several awards, including first place in the editorial writing category of the Associated Press/Oklahoma News Executives Carl Rogan Memorial News Excellence Competition for an editorial on the history of racism in the Oklahoma legislature.