Good Government

Stephen Moore | June 1, 2007

Liberalism's Echo Chambers

Stephen Moore

The Chamber of Commerce, long a supporter of limited government and low taxes, was part of the coalition backing the Reagan revolution in the 1980s. On the national level, the organization still follows a pro-growth agenda—but thanks to an astonishing political transformation, many chambers of commerce on the state and local level have been abandoning these goals. They're becoming, in effect, lobbyists for big government.

In Colorado, a coalition of property owners, conservative think tanks, anti-tax groups, and small businesses fought against a ballot initiative in 2005 that was intended to gut the state's Taxpayer Bill of Rights (TABOR). They lost, and as a result state spending will expand by $5 billion over the next five years, costing the average family several thousand dollars in higher taxes. It was not the teachers' unions or class-warfare liberals who spearheaded the campaign against TABOR, however—it was the Denver Chamber of Commerce. "This was just one depressing example of how everything bad that happens in Colorado," says Jon Caldara, president of the Independence Institute, "happens with the chamber's endorsement." And not just in Colorado.

In Virginia, the state and local chambers, along with big-business allies, have spent more than $4 million in recent years on ballot initiatives and legislative lobbying to raise $2 billion in taxes for roads, rails, buses, and schools. This year they want a billion more for transportation, despite the state's multibillion-dollar surplus, and have even threatened to run candidates against fiscal conservatives in the legislature who take a "no new taxes" pledge.

In as many as half the states, state taxpayer organizations, free-market think tanks, and small business leaders now complain bitterly that, on a wide range of issues, chambers of commerce deploy their financial resources and lobbying clout to expand the taxing, spending, and regulatory authorities of government. This behavior, they note, erodes the very pro-growth climate necessary for businesses—at least those not connected at the hip with government—to prosper. Journalist Tim Carney agrees: All too often, he notes in his recent book, The Big Ripoff: How Big Business and Big Government Steal Your Money, "state and local chambers have become corrupted by the lure of big dollar corporate welfare schemes."

In New Jersey—home of some of the worst schools in the nation—the state chamber took out an ad with the teachers' unions opposing a school-voucher initiative for families in inner cities. The ad was withdrawn only after pro-school-reform business members hollered in protest. Last summer taxpayers revolted when Democratic Gov. Jon Corzine called for a $1.5 billion hike in the sales tax; but "the chamber and other business groups sat on their hands in order to avoid making enemies with the legislature," notes Frayda Levin, New Jersey director of Americans for Prosperity.

In Oklahoma the state chamber filed a petition with the state Supreme Court to block eminent domain reform, and vowed to fight a taxpayer-led movement to enact a Colorado-style TABOR. Massachusetts? The state chamber and allied business groups oppose an income tax cut.

The picture isn't all bleak: The New York and Rhode Island state chambers, for example, struggle unflinchingly for low taxes, less regulation, and expenditure control. But they are becoming the exceptions. More common is the situation in states such as Maryland. Last November Maryland local chambers announced candidate endorsements: almost all the candidates were the incumbent power holders who voted for an increase in the minimum wage.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce boasts that the organization's "core mission is to fight for business and free enterprise before Congress, the White House, regulatory agencies, and governments around the world." The national chamber has done just that, pushing tort reform and free trade—but in the states, chambers have come to believe their primary function is to secure tax financing for sports stadiums, convention centers, high-tech research institutes, and transit boondoggles. Some local chambers have reportedly asked local utilities, school administrators, and even politicians to join; others have opened membership to arts councils, museums, civic associations and other "tax eater" entities [see sidebar].

Business owners are beginning to get fed up. In Hawaii, the chamber's cheerleading for higher taxes has caused hundreds of small business members to quit. (Since the early 1990s the chamber has supported three major tax hikes, including a recent a 12 percent increase in the state gross income tax to fund boondoggle transportation and rail projects.) In Maryland, small business membership is falling. Ellen Valentino, director of the Maryland National Federation of Independent Business, says that while the Maryland chamber provides PAC funds to its political adversaries, "Our membership wouldn't tolerate that."

"I used to think that public employee unions like the NEA were the main enemy in the struggle for limited government, competition, and private sector solutions," says Mr. Caldara of the Independence Institute. "I was wrong. Our biggest adversary is the special-interest business cartel that labels itself 'the business community' and its political machine run by chambers and other industry associations."

Stephen Moore (M.A., George Mason University) is the senior economics writer for The Wall Street Journal and a member of its editorial board. He previously served as the Grover M. Hermann Fellow in Budgetary Affairs at The Heritage Foundation. This article appeared February 10 in the Journal and is reprinted here with permission.

Tax Consumers Populate Chamber of Commerce Membership Rolls

In recent years chambers of commerce in this state have done yeoman's work in fighting for important policies such as Right to Work, workers' compensation reform, and lawsuit reform. However, many of these same chambers also lobby strenuously for bigger government, including increased funding for medical welfare programs and for the state's bottomless-pit education monopoly. These chambers lobby against prudent fiscal measures, such as one (not exactly draconian) proposal which would limit the annual growth of state government spending to 9.5 percent. Why is this?

Part of the answer can be found by examining the chambers' membership rosters. In addition to scads of nonprofit organizations (which may or may not receive taxpayer money), one discovers more than a few blatant "'tax eater' entities," to borrow Stephen Moore's phrase. Below are some examples (the lists aren't exhaustive) of tax eaters in two of Oklahoma's largest chambers.


Metro Tulsa Chamber
Tulsa Job Corps Center
Tulsa County Assessor
Tulsa City-County Health Department
Oklahoma House of Representatives
City of Collinsville
City of Bixby
City of Sand Springs
City of Tulsa
U. S. Army Recruiting Headquarters
U. S. Dept. of Energy/National Energy Technology Laboratory
Mayor's Office of Workforce Development-Downtown Tulsa Career Center
Oklahoma Aquarium
River Parks Authority
Tulsa Public Schools
Tulsa School of Arts and Sciences
Union Public Schools
Deborah Brown Community School
Dove Science Academy
Tulsa Technology Center
Langston University-Tulsa
Northeastern State University
Oklahoma State University
Oklahoma State University Center for Health Sciences College of Osteopathic Medicine
Oklahoma State University-Tulsa
Rogers State University
Tulsa Community College
University of Oklahoma-Tulsa
Department of Human Services
Workforce Oklahoma/Oklahoma State Employment Service
Workforce Tulsa

Greater Oklahoma City Chamber
Francis Tuttle Technology Center-Rockwell Campus
Shawnee Tribal Development
Downtown College Consortium
Oklahoma State Regents for Higher Education
Oklahoma State University-Office of Career Services
Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality/CSD
Oklahoma Lottery Commission
Oklahoma City West Army Recruiting Office
Association of Central Oklahoma Governments
City of Oklahoma City
Congresswoman Mary Fallin
Native American Cultural & Educational Authority
Oklahoma City Water Utilities Trust/Environmental Assistance Trust
Oklahoma County District Attorney's Office
Oklahoma County Sheriff's Office
Oklahoma Department of Transportation
Oklahoma Housing Finance Agency
Town of Arcadia
Workforce Oklahoma Career Connection Center
Oklahoma Federal Executive Board
Oklahoma City-County Health Department
Oklahoma City Indian Clinic
Metropolitan Library System
Belle Isle Library
Capitol Hill Library
Ralph Ellison Library
Southern Oaks Library
Warr Acres Library
Wright Extension Library
The Memorial Institute for the Prevention of Terrorism
Moore Norman Technology Center-Franklin Road Campus
Moore Norman Technology Center-South Penn Campus
KIPP Reach College Prep
Millwood Public Schools
Oklahoma City Public Schools
Oklahoma School of Science and Mathematics
Putnam City Schools
Langston University
University of Oklahoma College of Nursing
Oklahoma State University
University of Central Oklahoma
Langston University at Oklahoma City
Oklahoma Health Center Foundation-OU Health Sciences Center
Oklahoma City Community College
Oklahoma State University-Oklahoma City
Rose State College
Small Business Development Center-Langston University
University of Oklahoma
University of Oklahoma Athletics-Group Sales
University of Oklahoma College of Medicine
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center
Metro Technology Centers
Advanced Science Technology & Education Center
Community Action Agency of OKC and Oklahoma/Canadian Counties
Crime Stoppers-Oklahoma City Police Department


Stephen Moore

Loading Next